What are the premises in the arbitrariness argument against the divine command theory?

What are the premises in the arbitrariness argument against the divine command theory P 10?

What are the premises in the arbitrariness argument against the divine command theory? If God commanded an action, the command would be without reason and neither the believer nor the non-believer would think this state of affairs plausible.

What are some arguments against the divine command theory?

An argument often used against divine command theory is the problem of abhorrent acts. Divine command supports the possibility of God being able to command abhorrent acts if He so chooses, which would mean (for example) that murder, rape, and genocide would be morally acceptable.

What are the main objections to divine command theory?

These objections include the Euthyphro problem, the arbitrariness objection, the autonomy objection, the prior obligations objection (often called the Cudworth objection), the supervenience objection, and an objection based on the fact that God’s commands must be made known or promulgated.

THIS IS INTERESTING:  What is a divine human?

Why is the divine command theory arbitrary?

‘Divine Command Theory’ is the theory that what makes something morally right is that God commands it, and what makes something morally wrong is that God forbids it. … This article is a reply to the first of these objections, that divine command theory makes morality arbitrary.

What is the divine command theory in philosophy?

Roughly, Divine Command Theory is the view that morality is somehow dependent upon God, and that moral obligation consists in obedience to God’s commands.

What is the arbitrariness problem?

An objection levelled against *moral voluntarist positions, especially the *divine command theory. In its most prominent form, the objection states that if acts are right simply because God commands them, then any action would be right if God were to command it.

What are the limitations of divine command theory?

The challenges against Divine Command Theory means that it is difficult to apply to modern life. The incompatibility with our understanding of the world makes it difficult to justify wide-spread acceptance of it.

What are some objections to moral relativism?

In the eyes of many critics, though, the most serious objection to moral relativism is that it implies the pernicious consequence that “anything goes”: slavery is just according to the norms of a slave society; sexist practices are right according to the values of a sexist culture.

Why does Leibniz reject the divine command theory?

Leibniz, for example, rejects the divine command theory, declaring that it implies that God is unworthy of worship. In any case, it seems that through critical reasoning we can indeed learn much about morality and the moral life.

THIS IS INTERESTING:  Who is the god of divination?

What is the euthyphro objection to the divine command theory ‘?

We’d have to say that, e.g., torturing children is wrong because God condemns it. That is, all that makes it wrong is God’s condemning it. … Namely, God’s decrees aren’t arbitrary; God wouldn’t will that we torture children, for torturing children is wrong and God would never will us to do anything wrong.

What kind of moral contradictions or inconsistencies confront religious believers?

What kinds of moral contradictions or inconsistencies confront religious believers? Religious moral codes and other major religious rules of conduct are too vague to omit interpretation, which depends on ethics. What are the premises in the arbitrariness argument against the divine command theory?

What is acceptable by divine law?

Divine law is eternal law, meaning that since God is infinite, then his law must also be infinite and eternal. In Thomas Aquinas’s Treatise on Law, divine law, as opposed to natural law, comes only from revelation or scripture, hence biblical law, and is necessary for human salvation.

What is the importance of divine command theory?

The theory asserts that what is moral is determined by what God commands, and that for a person to be moral is to follow his commands. Followers of both monotheistic and polytheistic religions in ancient and modern times have often accepted the importance of God’s commands in establishing morality.

What is the divine right theory?

divine right of kings, in European history, a political doctrine in defense of monarchical absolutism, which asserted that kings derived their authority from God and could not therefore be held accountable for their actions by any earthly authority such as a parliament.

THIS IS INTERESTING:  What does divine beauty mean?

What is divine nature theory?

The Divine Nature Theory concisely argues that the nature of God is what is morally good. … However, because God has made His nature known through the Bible and nature, people could know what is morally good. Therefore, His revelations teach what is morally good.